PIES

Fresh Ingredients. Real Flavors.

All your favorites, from A-Z

Fruit & Pecan Pies: $17
Minis $6.; with ice cream: $6.50

Apple

Berry Bash (Marion berry, blueberry, cranberry, raspberry)

Blackberry

Blueberry

Cherry

Cherry Cranberry

Cranberry Apple Walnut

Cranberry Pear

Cranberry White Chocolate

Marionberry

Marionberry Cranberry

Peach

Peach Cranberry

Pineapple

Puckerberry (Rhubarb Cranberry

Raspberry

Raspberry Cranberry

Raspberry Peach

Rhubarb

Rhubarb Raspberry

Strawberry Rhubarb

Creams, Meringues, Lemon, Key Lime, & Custard Pies: $18.

Banana Cream

Cheese Pie

Chocolate Cream

Coconut Cream

Eggnog Cream

Key Lime

Lemon Meringue

Pumpkin: $15.

Crumb Pies: $17
Minis $6.; with ice cream: $6.50

Dutch Apple

Dutch Caramel Apple

Blueberry Cranberry Crumb

Blueberry Crumb

Cherry Crub

Peach Crumb

Peach Blueberry Crumb

Seasonal Pies: $17
Minis $6.; with ice cream: $6.50

Huckleberry

Mincemeat

Pecan

Pecan Cranberry

Pumpkin Pecan

Pumpkin Caramel Pecan

Fresh Strawberry: $18.

Wild Mountain Blackberry

Follow the Pie Lady on Facebook to see what's hot out of the oven!

Sugar Free Pies: $18
Minis $7
Gluten + Sugar Free Fruit Pies: $22

  • Whipped cream is available, but it is not sugar-free.
  • We do not have a sugar-free crumble topping.

Gluten Free Pies: $18
Minis $7
Gluten + Sugar Free Fruit Pies: $22

  • We do not have a gluten-free graham cracker crust.

Gluten Free Bundt Cakes: $22
Minis $6.50

  • Lemon
  • Chocolate
  • Blueberry

Gluten Free Cookies: 65¢ ea, 3/$1.50

Substitutions

  • Graham cracker crust on any pie: $2.  (order 1 day ahead)

Large Orders

  • We’ll do what we can to accommodate you.  Please call ahead! (971) 254-7142